Official fired after refusing to call Black postgraduate ‘Doctor’ on Zoom despite her correcting him twice

A city council in North Carolina fired a white official who refused to use the honorific “doctor” for a Black woman even after she corrected him several times during a zoning commission meeting last week.

On Tuesday night, the Greensboro City Council decided to let go one of its Zoning Commission members, Tony Collins, for being “disrespectful” toward the Black resident, Dr Carrie Rosario.

The meeting, which was televised live a day before, saw some heated exchanges between Mr Collins and Dr Rosario after he refused to use her honorific when addressing her.

Sharon Hightower, a city councilwoman, said: “It was a very disrespectful exchange between an important commissioner and a public citizen. That should never happen.”

Dr Rosario, 38, is an associate professor at the University of North Carolina-Greensboro and holds a doctorate in public health.

Councilwoman Hightower, who led the charge by calling the vote for Mr Collins removal, told McClatchy News: “As a Black female, I am not going to see another Black female treated in this manner.” 

The Greensboro City Council voted unanimously Tuesday night to remove Tony Collins from the Zoning Commission following a tense exchange during a commission meeting that involved Dr. Carrie Rosario, an associate professor at UNC-Greensboro.

The blatant disrespect 😤 pic.twitter.com/Y9ZakjhMsj

— Natasha ⚯͛ (@ndelriego) April 23, 2021

 

The incident took place toward the end of a four-hour-long Zoning Commission meeting. Dr Rosario had expressed concerns about a new development project near her home. At one point during the meeting, Mr Collins said that Dr Rosario’s response was veering off-topic and called her Mrs Rosario. She immediately corrected him and said: “It’s Dr Rosario. Thank you, sir.”

Mr Collins ignored her request and again refused to call her Dr Rosario. She again corrected him. At another point, he called her by her first name, Carrie. To that Dr Rosario relied: “It’s Dr Rosario. I wouldn’t call you Tony, so please, sir, call me as I would like to be called.”

The @HER_Lab_Elon stands in solidarity with Dr. Carrie Rosario @cmrosari and all Black women who have been disrespected, dismissed and undervalued. As co-founders who are Black women with doctoral degrees, trust and believe, we get it. https://t.co/dYa0rFaLS9 pic.twitter.com/c67D3C6EFV

— H.E.R._Lab (@HER_Lab_Elon) April 23, 2021

At this point, Mr Collins said: “It doesn’t really matter.” And to this, Dr Rosario said: “It matters to me. And out of respect, I would like you to call me by the name that I’m asking you to call me by.”

Dr Rosario has said that his refusal to address her as she wanted to during the meeting felt like a “personal attack of disrespect.” She told Madamenoire that she tried to give him the benefit of doubt at first, “but as the exchange unfolded it was clear that he was intent on disrespecting me. I was hurt, upset, angry — because this was a public forum — and the public should feel safe to be themselves, to present their concerns, and feel respected in the process.”

Councilwoman Sharon Hightower said that zoning board member Tony Collins was exercising “white privilege” for refusing to refer to Dr. Carrie Rosario as “doctor” after she requested he do so. https://t.co/HUisu0HhhW

— Winston-Salem Journal (@JournalNow) April 22, 2021

After being fired from the Zoning Commission, Mr Collins reached out to Dr Rosario and apologised, she said. Speaking more broadly about micro-aggressions faced by Black women all across the country, Dr Rosario said: “I would love to say that people don’t operate off of appearances, but that has not been my experience. Black women, regardless of level of education, are consistently dismissed and overlooked or judged in our society.”

I believe the comments of this biased article reflect exactly why I chose to use my title in the first place. Black women are not respected in our society. This article is evidence of it. A 🧵 https://t.co/lnU1DQEQ2c

— Carrie Rosario, DrPH (@cmrosari) April 22, 2021

Meanwhile, Greensboro News & Record reported that Councilwoman Hightower told other council members that Mr Collins was using his “white privilege” by continuously refusing Dr Rosario’s request. She said she was angry when she watched the exchange and that: “It is not going to be tolerated.”

Shining a light on what is so wrong and what is so right. Thank you Dr Carrie Rosario @cmrosari! https://t.co/jpLRZrRRyM

— Kathleen Roe (@KathleenMRoe) April 26, 2021

Dr Rosario told The Lily, that as a Black woman who says she looks young for her age, people tend to dismiss her opinion and expertise. “It [the title] adds legitimacy to what I’m saying.”